Do we really need a test to tell us whether our genes are sabotaging our efforts to get fit?
A burgeoning industry is being built on the promise that genetic tests can predict how individuals are likely to respond to exercise and at which types of physical activity they may do best, an alluring concept for those who have struggled to get fit for years and never seem to see the same results as others.
As scientists gain a better understanding of genes, companies specializing in exercise-related genetic tests are cropping up. XRGenomics is one of the newest in the field. The company developed a test designed to look at a persons genes to predict whether they can easily improve their VO2 max, or their capacity for aerobic exercise. Simply put, the higher your VO2 max, the longer and harder you can exercise.
The company says its test, available through its website, is different from many of its competitors, particularly because it is based on clinical research and it looks at a higher number of genes.
The test focuses on genes linked to the bodys maximum capacity to carry oxygen to muscles during exercise. It can give people useful, accurate information to help them improve their physical health, says James Timmons, the companys director and a professor of systems biology at Loughborough University in Britain.
The genetic test is suited for everyone, Timmons said, whether physically fit or not. We see it as potentially a motivation tool for both ends of the spectrum, he said.
Even so, the idea raises numerous questions about how valuable such information is and whether the results are as empowering as proponents claim.
The XRGenomics test is designed to detect genetic patterns that make some individuals low responders to exercise. In other words, it can spot individuals who have a difficult time improving their aerobic capacity. About 20 per cent of the population falls into that category, according to Timmons. That means 80 per cent of people dont face any particular challenge if they want to increase their ability to exercise.
Even if people are considered low responders under the XRGenomics test, they can still improve their VO2 max levels through working out. Theyll finish the race, even if they wont bring home a medal.
And genes only tell one part of the story. While they may be a big component, many other factors are at play that help determine aerobic capacity, such as diet and how much effort individuals put into exercise.
See the original post:
Can genetic tests help you build a better workout?